Meet the best alternative to ReplyGuy.com

ReplyGuy introduced the concept of AI-assisted commenting—but if you're looking for real growth, deeper automation, and brand-safe execution, Commentions is the smarter choice.

Here’s why more creators, marketers, and brands are switching from ReplyGuy to Commentions to take full control of their visibility across the web.

Get Started for Free with Commentions

Reason #1

Go beyond replies. Start automated brand mentions at scale

ReplyGuy helps you monitor certain keywords and offers replies to posts on X (formerly Twitter). It’s a solid concept—but limited in reach and automation.With Commentions, you unlock the ability to:
‍
- Engage across X, YouTube, and Quora from a single dashboard
- Automatically mention your product, service, or brand in high-visibility posts
- Scale your visibility strategy with zero manual effort

In other words: Commentions doesn’t just help you comment, it helps you get noticed, remembered, and clicked.

Reason #2

Smarter replies = stronger brand perception

The problem with basic keyword-matching tools like ReplyGuy? They often produce generic or robotic replies that add little value, and sometimes even feel spammy.
‍Commentions is built differently.
Its AI reads the full context of a post, including:

X threads and replies
YouTube transcripts and comment chains
Quora answers and question phrasing

Then, it crafts comments that sound authentic, relevant, and engaging, designed to spark curiosity and invite clicks to your site or profile.It’s like having a smart brand ambassador commenting for you—24/7.

Reason #3

Full automation, not just suggestions

With ReplyGuy, you’re still responsible for copy-pasting replies, switching tabs, and pressing send. That doesn’t scale—and worse, it puts your accounts at risk if you start using aggressive automation extensions.

Commentions automates the entire workflow:

Detects relevant content based on your target keywords or topics
Generates natural-sounding replies that match your brand tone
Publishes them automatically on your behalf
Tracks how each comment performs (impressions, clicks, CTR)

You get real outcomes, without micromanaging every comment.

Twitter X example of posts commented by an AI named commentions

Quora example of posts commented by an AI named commentions

Youtube example of posts commented by an AI named commentions bot

Reason #4

Designed for serious marketing use. Not just “reply guy” hustle

ReplyGuy is popular with indie hackers and solopreneurs, but it wasn't built for professional workflows or scale.
‍Commentions, on the other hand, supports:

Personal brands (e.g. coaches, consultants, creators)
SaaS and DTC businesses looking to generate warm leads
Crypto and Web3 projects that want to appear in relevant discussions
Marketing agencies managing multiple brands at once

You can define your tone (friendly, expert, witty...), pick your languages, and tailor replies by vertical, so you sound on-brand every time.

Comparison

Feature Comparison

Feature

ReplyGuy

Commentions

Platforms

X, Reddit (manual)

✅ X, YouTube, Quora (fully automated)

Automation

Generates suggestions only

✅ Detects, writes & posts comments autonomously

Context Understanding

Basic keyword scan

✅ Full content analysis + semantic understanding

Comment Quality

Often generic or repetitive

✅ Context-aware, tone-controlled, human-sounding

Posting method

Manual or browser extension

✅ API-compliant automation without extensions

Safety & compliance

Risk of bans due to method

✅ Safe pacing, tone variation, and native posting

Tracking & analytics

None

✅ Dashboard with CTR, impressions, top-performing content

Personalization & tone

Limited

✅ Personal brands, SaaS, agencies, crypto, creators

Meet the best alternative to ReplyGuy.com

Go beyond replies. Start automated brand mentions at scale

Smarter replies = stronger brand perception

Full automation, not just suggestions

Designed for serious marketing use. Not just “reply guy” hustle

Feature Comparison

Automate your growth starting today

For brands

For agencies

Crypto creators

For startups

Product

Social

Use Cases

Alternatives